My first run out on Hoka trail shoes was a bit of an unfair test for any shoe. I am out of shape, nursing along a meniscal tear until I can work getting it fixed in my schedule and it just snowed 15” on the benches earlier in the week. This followed by temps in the 60s have turned the trails into a sloppy nightmare. This week Dry Creek was anything but.
My overall takeaway is very favorable, I have been skeptical since I first saw these shoes on the trail and after getting some miles in them, I truly feel they are not simply another gimmick shoe, but a game-changing shoe. That said, there are some limitations to this design as well, but most of those are the predictable trade-offs considering the design benefits of the sole.
The main design feature of the shoe is the cushy sole that looks a bit like a trail shoe has mated with a hovercraft and this is the unholy byproduct. Aesthetically, this shoe looks like they put Aunt Ethyl on the cover of the swimsuit edition, but the trail credo isn’t really ‘dress to impress’ anyway! Before trying the shoe, I was concerned that the experience would be like running on a bag of marshmallows and every foot plant would be squishing along unsteadily. In reality, I’m quite impressed with the run feel of the shoes. From go, they felt like a good running shoe with a solid plant, stride base and toe-off. I have a half mile on pavement until I get to my local trailhead, and from the first step, I liked the run feel on this surface.
The shoe really does a great job of accomplishing it’s main goal, or what I perceive to be the main goal, given the design. That of delivering a softer, less impactful run. The manner in which they accomplish this is primarily through attenuation of what are described as ground-reactive forces. This has to do with Newton’s Third Law of Motion, which is often summarized as “For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.” In running, this means that whatever force I strike the ground with, the ground strikes me back equally. These forces are manifested as impaction and vibrational force that occurs with every heel-strike, and loads of stabilizing muscles are engaged to counter these ground-reactive forces before you even get to propel along to the next stride. We use up lots of energy dealing with landing our foot on the ground, and wouldn’t it be nice to save some of that energy for something else...like running farther? It is a similar principal to why it’s nicer to ride a carbon fiber road bike than a steel frame. I never understood how much ‘road vibration’ I was absorbing and how much energy it took out of me on my old steel Bianchi until I bought an Orbea that was carbon fiber. This shoe is a similar game changer. Cutting these forces has vast implications for runners, some of which you feel as soon as you put them on, but some may be discovered over longer term. Lessening the ground reaction forces on your joints may add miles on your daily run, but it also may add years to your running career.
The feel of this shoe on the trail is exactly what you hope it would be, soft on the landing but no squishy marshmallow feel as you power out your stride. It can accelerate uphill with conviction. Striding out on a rare, dry, flatter portion of the trail, the shoe really shined as it smoothed out the rough edges of the trail and my gait, letting me fly along with silky abandon. I was reminded of an old commercial where they drove a car over bumps, but the ride was so smooth, a jeweler could precisely cut a diamond in the back seat.
So what are the concerns? One of the first things I noticed on my run was that this is definitely not a snow shoe. Interestingly, what provided good traction on flatter dirt and mildly rocky terrain went completely pear-shaped on snow. I found that even on wet dirt and scree, the shoe did admirably as long as I was traveling in a straight line. The real slick stuff, like mud and snow was completely dicey and I had a couple ‘close ones.’ I thought about this a bit like when you go Jeeping in Moab and take some of the air out of your tires for better traction on boulders. I think this gave the shoe better traction than I expected over a lot of the trail, but it didn’t hold up to the mud & snow.
The other big trail issue is a natural trade-off of the design. The thicker sole moves you away from the ground and any side-hill boulders will produce more stress and instability. There is a definite risk of rolling an ankle if you lose your focus in more technical terrain. For rocky trails with a lot of technical, off-camber hills this is not a beginner shoe. You need to be solid in your line and have experience in anticipating the trail, with strength to stabilize and power through the wobbles as rocks throw you a bit more than with a lower sole.
Finally, the fit of the upper was a little basic. It does not have some of the contoured detail or grip points that some other shoes have so I felt more of a disconnect between my foot and the shoe than I expected. I seem to have a reasonably universal foot, and even right out of the box, I can wear many brands without seeing fit problems. I had a lot of heel slip in the Hokas and ended up re-tying the shoe twice in the first 30 minutes of the run. Fortunately, the soaking wet and muddy run seemed to shrink the shoe around my foot some and I’m hoping it stiffens to my fit a little better for the next run.
In summary, the Hoka is really not like any other shoe in many ways and most of those are very good things. I see this as a game-changing shoe that is early in it’s development, with some issues to address, but overall a design principle that is remarkable in how it conserves energy and decreases the physical toll on your body. I see the design of this shoe having great impact in the road running community as the brand evolves. For technical terrain, it’s more of an expert shoe and I would recommend a little caution if you don’t have solid trail legs. I plan to use this shoe through the summer and I’m sure I will have more impressions as I gain experience with it. I will probably alternate with another shoe in training to get some ‘trail hardening’ to my legs when I want a little more work and effort in my run (seriously, I’m a little concerned that the Hoka makes the run too easy!). But, at this point, I plan to use this as my race shoe, and am excited to have a little secret advantage as I point my training toward the Wasatch 100 at the end of the Summer.

No comments:
Post a Comment